The tiny 99-seat Sierra Madre Playhouse disappears quickly in its production of John Patrick Shanley’s wistful (no other word works), kinda funny Irish romance, “Outside Mullingar.”
The historic theater has been transformed into a modest cattle and sheep farm outside Killucan, Ireland, where Anthony Reilly (Michael Kirby) and his father, Tony (Armin Shimerman), have just returned from a funeral. Rain, death and the stubborn business of keeping a farm going hang over the room.
Then Tony delivers some news.
Anthony won’t be getting the farm when his father dies.
“You don’t love the farm,” Tony tells him.
And that’s all the plot you get.
What follows is better discovered in Shanley’s own peculiar rhythm, which moves between melancholy, argument, romance and some wonderfully dry comedy. The production is smart and lively, even as its characters carry around the emotional weight of generations, along with thick Irish brogues of which they are no doubt proud.
Set over five years beginning in 2008, “Outside Mullingar” somehow feels much older, as though these people might have been having essentially the same conversations around the same kitchen table fifty years earlier. But every emotion here has been around since water: loneliness, resentment, pride, desire and the terrifying possibility that someone might actually know you.
Kirby gives Anthony an appealing awkwardness, a man more comfortable with land and weather than with explaining himself. Shimerman’s Tony is tougher and more pragmatic, but never merely hard. Their early exchanges establish the production’s lovely balance between affection and combat.
Liza Seneca is emphatic and wonderfully determined as neighboring Rosemary Muldoon, who seems to hold the Reillys’ future in her hands while pursuing a future of her own. Kitty Swink plays Rosemary’s mother, Aoife, with an earthy directness, as plain and elemental as the farm’s soil.
The intimate space works beautifully for Shanley’s story. The set is simple and clever, with the actors themselves pushing the rotating stage between scenes, turning a farmhouse kitchen into a backyard, then a neighboring dining room, and back again. Rather than interrupting the illusion, the transformations become part of it. These people literally move their small world around one another.
“Outside Mullingar” is ultimately about people who have spent years living only a few feet apart while somehow remaining miles away.
At Sierra Madre Playhouse, those few feet feel very close indeed.
“Outside Mullingar” runs Oct. 2 through Oct. 25, 2026, for 16 performances at Sierra Madre Playhouse, 87 W. Sierra Madre Blvd., Sierra Madre. 626.355.4318.


